I needed a few extra pulls, so I ordered from the same web page, same design, same product number. When these arrived, they were noticeably lighter in weight and more matte than satin finish.
The selection page only offered "black," not satin or matte finish.
The handles look enough like the first order, so I will keep them, but something happened in the three weeks between orders that you might check on with your supplier.
The pulls and knobs are unique, very crisp and contemporary without being "out there." They have a nice heft and are not in the least bit flimsy or cheap looking. I am just thrilled with them and in fact re-ordered to put in my bathroom. I used all pulls in the kitchen and knobs and pulls for the built in's in the dining room. The all pull look is beautiful.